| Lotto Draft | |||||
| Wolfram & Hart | Exec:Matt Wieters | Jason Heyward | Tim Beckham | Kyle Skipworth | Yonder Alonso |
| Padres | W&H: Rick Porcello | Matt Latos | Wade LeBlanc | Casey Weathers | Mizz: James Simmons |
| J24ktarm | Johnny Cueto | Brook: Josh Vitters | Brook: Justin Masterson | Mizz: Joe Savery | Exec: Daniel Cortes |
| Tri-State Titans | Pess: Wade Davis | Brook: Jarrod Parker | Pess: Chris Marrero | Brook: Huroki Kuroda | Brook: M. Bumgarner |
| Flash Gordon is Old | Shup: Phillipe Aumont | W&H: Pedro Alvarez | Brook: Desmond Jennings | Jordan Walden | Sour: Trevor Cahill |
| Garlic Munchers | Gio Gonzalez | Kosuke Fukudome | W&H: Brian Matusz | Brett Sinkbeil | Michael Bowden |
| The Incognators | Sour: Matt LaPorta | Sour: Max Scherzer | Sour: Aaron Crow | J24: Chorye Spoone | Shup: Michael Almanzar |
| Execution Style | Sour: Brett Anderson | Sour: Justin Smoak | Otto: Austin Jackson | Pess: Neftali Feliz | Flash: Alan Horne |
| Missouri McChickens | Mike Moustakas | Angel Villalona | Tim Alderson | Lars Anderson | James McDonald |
| Shapezilla | Sour: Fauti De Los Santos | Exec: Jordan Schafer | Otto: Greg Reynolds | Sour: Jed Lowrie | Sour: Beau Mills |
| Regular Draft | |||||
| Wolfram & Hart | Juan Duran | Yu Darvish | Gordon Beckham | Sour: Wilson Ramos | Josh Fields |
| Bkyln Royal Giants | J24: T. Teagarden | Chris Davis | J24: Edward Salacedo | Mizz: Gorkys Hernandez | Incog: Nick Blackburn |
| Galletti's Galaxy | Otto: Chris Perez | Sour: H.A. Rodriguez | Mizz: Brett Cecil | Adam Ottavino | Taylor Green |
| Anderson Nightmares | Pads: Blake Beaven | Pads: Chris Withrow | J24: Jake Arrieta | Mizz: Matt Dominguez | J24: Nick Hagadone |
| SourMan | Pads: Michael Main | Pads: Kyle Banks | Shup: Daniel Moskos | Otto: Preston Guilmet | W&H: Jacob Thompson |
| Pessimistic Players | Brook: Hank Conger | Otto: Weed Smoker | Otto: Aaron Poreda | Michael Burgess | Dexter Fowler |
| Hounds | W&H: Julio Teheran | Galaxy: Kevin Mulvey | W&H: Tim Melville | W&H: Buster Posey | Matt Maloney |
| Otto the Orange | Sour: Chris Carter | Adrian Cardenas | VOID | W&H: Tanner Scheppers | Shup: Juan Ramirez |
| Seattle Shupurrs | Tyson Ross | W&H: Cole Rohrbough | Incog: Brent Lillibridge | W&H: Eric Hosmer | Shup: Kellen Kulbacki |